When I entered the Solicitors profession - It was as a 'junior bag carrier' to an experienced, expert and (by many) trusted business counsel to a significant men of business.
Over the years, in some small way I have evolved into the latter (with certain clients), but far too often I come upon younger men who buy all the goods for their business via Alibaba, and think that you deal with professional advisers in the same way.
I am going to draw you analogy with my recent engagement of a plumber.
The need for a plumber came about because I had a slow draining sink (to my belief and annoyance – due to my own foolhardiness in repeatedly emptying coffee grounds into that sink).
I was faced with spending a considerable proportion of my forthcoming weekend dealing with problem myself - removing a u-bend & cleaning it out, then possibly rodding a pipe in a wall (and hoping that cleared any blockage further into the drainage system) and that my attempt(s) to re-assemble everything went smoothly and easily = I just couldn’t face it.
Instead I engaged ‘Reg’ - a plumber with whom I have developed a mutually beneficial client / business relationship over twenty odd years of needing a good plumber in West London (+ Not easy!).
Reg knows that I will pay him a fair sum for his work, and I know that Ron will turn up on time and 'sort' my plumbing problems.
I’m sure I could have spent a considerable period of time online comparing plumbers I’d never met before (and / or would be unlikely to ever see again) over what their minimum and ongoing charge out rate was etc.
Critically, I could have had them competitively quote for the relatively extensive work - which I as an inexpert / laymen envisaged might be necessary (See above).
I’m sure many of those I might have wished to engage by that process - would have carried out the relatively extensive work that I outlined I believed was needed, presenting me with a apparently competitive (but relatively extensive) bill.
What actually was arranged was that Reg said "Let me come & have a look at it, and I’ll ‘sort it’ on a ‘what the job deserves’ basis". I agreed.
On arrival, Ron looked at the problem, went back to his van and produced a wood & leather plunger (which he apparently was gifted by his apprentice master in the early 1970s – although it looked Victorian = "You can't get these now" etc.); and with a ‘special trick’ (which he imparted to me) he cleared the blockage completely in under a minute.
GBP £20 ‘cash payment’ later – we both parted as content men (until the next time I need him).
The point is that I simply cannot scope or time-budget much of the necessary work which people approach me with without either sight of relevant documentation and / or a sensible initial conversation with the individual who wants assistance – which I generally offer on a no-obligation basis.
There is a danger that unless you do this - you are encouraging a person in need of assistance to focus solely upon knowing ‘price’ and downplaying (to the point of ignoring) ‘value’.
For example, I've recently been approached by a prospective client who believed he needed two transaction documents, and wanted a quote for their production. It was rapidly clear to me that only one material document was required, for reasons that I explained in detail. It took the prospective client rather more time than I thought it would - to realise that those others who had quoted for what the prospective client erroneously believed he needed - were clearly displaying their lack of experience & expertise!
Too often, when asked to 'quote' for work – based upon what I then currently know – I am being asked to ‘quote for creating a piece of string’ – when I haven’t even had a chance to consider / concur that the client needs a piece of string / let alone how long it needs to be / and (accordingly) what it might cost!
My offer to prospective clients is clear – But to set it out - They should ideally provide me with some documentation and I will review the same upon a no-obligation basis (and the fact that many prospective client seem disinclined and / or unable to do this – is often a worrying sign in terms of working efficiently / keeping fees economic).
Additinally and / or alternatively, I habitually offer an initial no-obligation discussion with a prospective client as to the background and current circumstances – the combination of these two actions (documentation review & consultation) allowing me to scope and time budget proposed fees.
If the prospective client is happy with my time budget proposed fees then we might develop a business / client relationship as mutually beneficial as mine & Reg’s. If not – they have nothing to lose, but we almost certainly are both the losers in the long run.
I’ve said it before – but it’s worth repeating – if introducers help me to earn a fee, then there is business to go round –v- If introducers seek as their raison d’etre to drive down such fees I can earn = You cut your own throat!
Let me know if you wish to discuss any of the above aspects / issues
With best regards
DanielRobertJohnson (Skype)
www.linkedin.com/in/danrjohnson
www.EquitableLaw.com
+44 (0) 7788 537 187 : U.K. Cellular Tel.
+44 (0) 333 390 3525 : London Based / Global Roaming Voicemail
N.B. For the record – My plumber (Reg)’s house is worth about three times (x 3) as much as mine (a Solicitor) = Makes you think, doesn’t it!
A personal blog written by Mr. Dan Johnson with a broad connection to his Solicitors practice, www.EquitableLaw.com. Frequently written in haste = Often badly spelled, with appalling grammar and even (upon occasion) not finished; Reflecting its habitual rough-cut nature. The Mona Lisa was NOT painted in one sitting!
Tuesday, 14 March 2017
Monday, 13 March 2017
City Firms’ Trainee Retention Rates Falling - Law Society Gazette - February 2017
https://www.lawgazette.co.uk/law/city-firms-trainee-retention-rates-falling/5059944.article
On the basis that the training costs for a Solicitor now run into sums of tens (if not hundred plus) thousands of British Pounds (GBP £xx+,000s), any retention rate number materially below 100% show firms suffering wasted expenditure, at least in part caused by the relevant firms predictions of near future economic activity being less than that they forecast several years before.
When the second derivative (change of retention rate) is falling (as these figures appear to show), that may well be a worrying sign in terms of forecasting a technical recession for the economy.
English Trainee Solicitors may have to comfort themselves that at least they are not joining the Law Society of Scotland . . .
On the basis that the training costs for a Solicitor now run into sums of tens (if not hundred plus) thousands of British Pounds (GBP £xx+,000s), any retention rate number materially below 100% show firms suffering wasted expenditure, at least in part caused by the relevant firms predictions of near future economic activity being less than that they forecast several years before.
When the second derivative (change of retention rate) is falling (as these figures appear to show), that may well be a worrying sign in terms of forecasting a technical recession for the economy.
English Trainee Solicitors may have to comfort themselves that at least they are not joining the Law Society of Scotland . . .
Tuesday, 28 February 2017
ADVANCE SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENTS FOR FUNDING EARLY STAGE COMPANIES
Over recent periods, the venture capital industry has seen increasing use of 'advance subscription arrangements’ being used for making investments in early stage companies, in early seed rounds.
Most equity raises consist of what's known as a 'priced round', i.e. shares are issued at an agreed price per share at the point that the investment is made. Alternatively, the company or the investors may use a convertible loan note, under which the investment is initially made by way of debt, which later converts to shares when a future event takes place (for example, the next financing round or an exit).
The conversion price is usually set by that future event, for example a discount of 15-25% on the share price associated with that transaction. This has the advantage of postponing the difficult and contentious question of valuation. It also provides some downside protection for the investor, as the investment remains a debt that may become repayable, and ranks ahead of shareholders in the event of insolvency.
Tax Relief Implications
Whilst convertibles are used extensively in the U.S., they are not that common in the U.K., largely because they don't allow the investor to claim Seed Enterprise Investment Scheme (SEIS) or Enterprise Investment Scheme (EIS) relief on the investment.
An ‘advance subscription agreement’ seeks to address this. If structured correctly, it enables the investor to subscribe for shares, with funds being provided to the company at the date of the agreement, but with that investment converting to shares upon a future event (e.g. the next financing round).
However, the investor has no right to demand this money back. The investment has to convert to share capital at some point, which in the absence of another equity raise or exit, will be a specified date or an insolvency. This would mean that the investment no longer has the downside protection of a convertible loan, and may therefore be eligible for SEIS / EIS relief.
Key Features Of Advance Subscription Agreements
These arrangements can involve a variety of terms, although the core features to look out for are:
• Discount – the reduction in the share price for the advanced subscription investors when their shares convert into shares. We see 15% - 25% as being the market norm.
• Cap – the maximum value at which the investment will convert into shares, designed to ensure that the investor does not end up with an unexpectedly low equity percentage.
• Qualifying Threshold – a minimum size of the round that will trigger conversion (if the round is very small, the investor may prefer to wait until a more significant investment is made).
• Long Stop Conversion Price – the price per share that is used for the conversion if there is no funding or exit event to provide a third party valuation of the company.
Many early stage investors value the ability to agree specific terms governing their relationship with their investee company through a priced round. In particular, a warranty and disclosure process appeals, though of course these advantages could be delivered through a bespoke advanced subscription arrangement. It is an interesting tool for both investors and fast growing companies to be aware of.
If you'd like more information about any aspects of advance subscription agreements, please get in touch.
This publication is intended for general guidance and represents our understanding of the relevant law and practice as at February 2017.
Specific advice should be sought for specific cases. For more information see our terms & conditions.
Dan.Johnson@EquitableLaw.com
+44 (0) 333 390 3525 (U.K. Based / Worldwide Roaming e-Voicemail)
www.EquitableLaw.com
PRINTABLE PDF VERSION : https://files.acrobat.com/a/preview/470a751e-8708-4f10-b089-a99a2d44cd4d
Most equity raises consist of what's known as a 'priced round', i.e. shares are issued at an agreed price per share at the point that the investment is made. Alternatively, the company or the investors may use a convertible loan note, under which the investment is initially made by way of debt, which later converts to shares when a future event takes place (for example, the next financing round or an exit).
The conversion price is usually set by that future event, for example a discount of 15-25% on the share price associated with that transaction. This has the advantage of postponing the difficult and contentious question of valuation. It also provides some downside protection for the investor, as the investment remains a debt that may become repayable, and ranks ahead of shareholders in the event of insolvency.
Tax Relief Implications
Whilst convertibles are used extensively in the U.S., they are not that common in the U.K., largely because they don't allow the investor to claim Seed Enterprise Investment Scheme (SEIS) or Enterprise Investment Scheme (EIS) relief on the investment.
An ‘advance subscription agreement’ seeks to address this. If structured correctly, it enables the investor to subscribe for shares, with funds being provided to the company at the date of the agreement, but with that investment converting to shares upon a future event (e.g. the next financing round).
However, the investor has no right to demand this money back. The investment has to convert to share capital at some point, which in the absence of another equity raise or exit, will be a specified date or an insolvency. This would mean that the investment no longer has the downside protection of a convertible loan, and may therefore be eligible for SEIS / EIS relief.
Key Features Of Advance Subscription Agreements
These arrangements can involve a variety of terms, although the core features to look out for are:
• Discount – the reduction in the share price for the advanced subscription investors when their shares convert into shares. We see 15% - 25% as being the market norm.
• Cap – the maximum value at which the investment will convert into shares, designed to ensure that the investor does not end up with an unexpectedly low equity percentage.
• Qualifying Threshold – a minimum size of the round that will trigger conversion (if the round is very small, the investor may prefer to wait until a more significant investment is made).
• Long Stop Conversion Price – the price per share that is used for the conversion if there is no funding or exit event to provide a third party valuation of the company.
Many early stage investors value the ability to agree specific terms governing their relationship with their investee company through a priced round. In particular, a warranty and disclosure process appeals, though of course these advantages could be delivered through a bespoke advanced subscription arrangement. It is an interesting tool for both investors and fast growing companies to be aware of.
If you'd like more information about any aspects of advance subscription agreements, please get in touch.
This publication is intended for general guidance and represents our understanding of the relevant law and practice as at February 2017.
Specific advice should be sought for specific cases. For more information see our terms & conditions.
Dan.Johnson@EquitableLaw.com
+44 (0) 333 390 3525 (U.K. Based / Worldwide Roaming e-Voicemail)
www.EquitableLaw.com
PRINTABLE PDF VERSION : https://files.acrobat.com/a/preview/470a751e-8708-4f10-b089-a99a2d44cd4d
Monday, 2 January 2017
Business Law Awards 2016 - Equitable Law Awarded "Best Business Law Boutique"
We are delighted to announce
that Equitable Law has been awarded :–
Best Business Law Boutique -
Commercial Law Specialist of the Year - UK
In Corporate Vision Magazine's 2016
Business Law Awards.
The 2016 Business Law
Awards recognise the success and dedication of legal service providers working
across the globe and throughout this vast industry.
These awards are a great
achievement, and as such I am sure you will want to join me in congratulating the team upon this good news for 2017.
For further details, please do not hesitate to contact me :-
Dan.Johnson@EquitableLaw.com
Principal & Business Law Solicitor
+44 (0) 333 390 3525
Friday, 18 November 2016
Online Legal Advice In a Twenty-First Century World
I wanted to blog today about an issue which is concerning me more and more (on prospective clients' behalf) in this twenty-first century world.
People seem to be more and more driven to buy at the lowest price possible - without understanding what it is that they are really buying. While there might be some logic for this when you are buying a simple, understood manufactured product - when you apply that approach to obtaining legal advice & assistance services - you may well be 'asking for trouble'.
Not too long ago, people knew they needed legal advice, thought 'Solicitor' and then either asked their friends and family for a recomendation and / or looked under the reelvant section in the 'Yellow Pages' (let me know if you need me to explain that youngsters!).
Now - people seem to carry out an internet ('Google') search for 'lawyer' - and the results that I am seeing are horrific! I will try and blog on this further in a seprate piece - but this year I have seen a businessman lose his business entirely (had to be dissolved), and another receive but a fraction of the price on sale that they had been originally offerred - all due to the approach taken by the 'lawyer' they instructed!
Detailed background information with regard to my Solicitors practice is available (and is regularly updated) at:
www.EquitableLaw.com
Please be advised (if you are seeking to obtain legal advice & assistance in relation to business issues), that I would thoroughly recommend you use a person who can legitimately describe themselves and trade as a 'Solicitor' - who will be (generally) able to professionally advise and assist you in relation to all commercial, taxation and other relevant legal issues (and if they can't they'll tll you).
I AM a fully qualified and highly experienced English Solicitor, with my own authorised & regulated etc. Solicitors practice, "Equitable Law" - based in West / Central London, but trading both nationally & internationally.
Be warned - That in addition to those who trade on-line, and are reasonably open about their lack of qualifications, experience and / or expertise - there are a significant number of people who trade on-line - who use a variety of titles to describe themselves - which you should (please) appreciate signify next to nothing, if anything (e.g. 'lawyer', 'legal consultant' etc.).
It really doesn't matter if the relevant person / organisation provides a picture of themselves wearing a wig and / or have a picture of some law books (as their cover image / upon their web-site). Unless they can legitimately call themselves and trade as a "Solicitor", then it is unlikely that they are anything other than unqualified, unauthorised, unregulated, effectively uninsured (in practice - whatever they may claim) layman - as regards advising and assisting with English legal matters.
H.M. Govenment knows this and when they permit people providing legal services as a business to inter-react with them (e.g. the Courts, the Land Registry, the Probate Registry) they insist upon the relevant person being a Solicitor (or a small number of other recognised legal professionals - e.g. Barrister, Licensed Conveyancer etc.).
However, if you are not so dealing with H.M. Government - Public policy is to promote total competition (to which I have no objection) but you should recognise 'you are on your own' and 'it's like the Wild West out there'!
Many others who trade on-line assert themselves to be 'former' or 'retired' Solicitors - with regard to which, I would encourage you to ask the question - Why is it they no longer appear able to use their former title and yet seek to trade as 'legal advisors'? Raise the question whether the preface 'former' or 'retired' is in fact a euphemism for 'disbarred'?
Be particularly wary of those who claim to be 'Solicitors' - but who simply do not satisfy the obligations under English law to use that title and trade as such. There are a significant number of people trading with fake names, often based outside of the U.K. - although obscuring that point (and therefore beyond the reach of the regulatory authorities) and / or who otherwise are "wrong 'uns"!
Please check the Law Society's 'Find a Solicitor' database to establish whom it is you are dealing with.
This Solicitors practice is at :- http://solicitors.lawsociety.org.uk/office/545878/equitable-law-limited
My personal details are at:- http://solicitors.lawsociety.org.uk/person/9511/daniel-robert-johnson
Anyone else who is NOT included in that database (both as an individual AND in relation to the legal entity through which they trade) - will be omitted for a variety of reasons - most likely including an inability to satisfy the Solicitors' profession's regulator (directly or indirectly) as to ethics and / or competency (although there is much, much worse that I could advise you of - I am afraid!)
Please always remember that the general ultimate aim of seeking legal advice & assistance in relation to commercial / business matters, is to result in the possession of appropriate advice etc. and / or the production of documents - which you can legally rely upon and / or enforce in the future.
It is fully possible in circumstances (such as these) to opt for 'false economy' and pay for apparent 'legal' advice & assistance - that only much time later do you realise is worthless for your purposes and / or damaging for your position (and in relation to which - in practice - you have no 'comeback')!
If you are comfortable not receiving legal advice & assistance that you can rely upon (and I fully understand that in early stage businesses etc. this can be the case) - there are a range of on-line legal guides and libraries that I would be happy to guide you to - which ultimately are much more economic / cost-effective than paying inflated sums to someone who will simply be regurgitating information that they have fund on-line to you - with no understanding as to its accuracy / appropriateness etc.(at best)!
I sincerely hope that our first contact will not be when you wish to have a consultation with me about the prejudice and resulting losses that you have suffered from not instructing a Solicitor / having instructed the cheapest on-line advice and assistance option - as regrettably happens all too often!
I am always delighted to have preliminary contact with prospective clients upon an initial no obligation basis, so do please feel free to contact me for such a discussion.
I hope to receive contact from you - if you would like to discuss my potential legal advice & assistance further.
DanielRobertJohnson (Skype)
Dan.Johnson@EquitableLaw.com
+44 (0) 7788 537 187 (U.K. Cell. Tel.)
+44 (0) 20 8780 3319 (London Landline Tel.)
www.EquitableLaw.com
People seem to be more and more driven to buy at the lowest price possible - without understanding what it is that they are really buying. While there might be some logic for this when you are buying a simple, understood manufactured product - when you apply that approach to obtaining legal advice & assistance services - you may well be 'asking for trouble'.
Not too long ago, people knew they needed legal advice, thought 'Solicitor' and then either asked their friends and family for a recomendation and / or looked under the reelvant section in the 'Yellow Pages' (let me know if you need me to explain that youngsters!).
Now - people seem to carry out an internet ('Google') search for 'lawyer' - and the results that I am seeing are horrific! I will try and blog on this further in a seprate piece - but this year I have seen a businessman lose his business entirely (had to be dissolved), and another receive but a fraction of the price on sale that they had been originally offerred - all due to the approach taken by the 'lawyer' they instructed!
Detailed background information with regard to my Solicitors practice is available (and is regularly updated) at:
www.EquitableLaw.com
Please be advised (if you are seeking to obtain legal advice & assistance in relation to business issues), that I would thoroughly recommend you use a person who can legitimately describe themselves and trade as a 'Solicitor' - who will be (generally) able to professionally advise and assist you in relation to all commercial, taxation and other relevant legal issues (and if they can't they'll tll you).
I AM a fully qualified and highly experienced English Solicitor, with my own authorised & regulated etc. Solicitors practice, "Equitable Law" - based in West / Central London, but trading both nationally & internationally.
Be warned - That in addition to those who trade on-line, and are reasonably open about their lack of qualifications, experience and / or expertise - there are a significant number of people who trade on-line - who use a variety of titles to describe themselves - which you should (please) appreciate signify next to nothing, if anything (e.g. 'lawyer', 'legal consultant' etc.).
It really doesn't matter if the relevant person / organisation provides a picture of themselves wearing a wig and / or have a picture of some law books (as their cover image / upon their web-site). Unless they can legitimately call themselves and trade as a "Solicitor", then it is unlikely that they are anything other than unqualified, unauthorised, unregulated, effectively uninsured (in practice - whatever they may claim) layman - as regards advising and assisting with English legal matters.
H.M. Govenment knows this and when they permit people providing legal services as a business to inter-react with them (e.g. the Courts, the Land Registry, the Probate Registry) they insist upon the relevant person being a Solicitor (or a small number of other recognised legal professionals - e.g. Barrister, Licensed Conveyancer etc.).
However, if you are not so dealing with H.M. Government - Public policy is to promote total competition (to which I have no objection) but you should recognise 'you are on your own' and 'it's like the Wild West out there'!
Many others who trade on-line assert themselves to be 'former' or 'retired' Solicitors - with regard to which, I would encourage you to ask the question - Why is it they no longer appear able to use their former title and yet seek to trade as 'legal advisors'? Raise the question whether the preface 'former' or 'retired' is in fact a euphemism for 'disbarred'?
Be particularly wary of those who claim to be 'Solicitors' - but who simply do not satisfy the obligations under English law to use that title and trade as such. There are a significant number of people trading with fake names, often based outside of the U.K. - although obscuring that point (and therefore beyond the reach of the regulatory authorities) and / or who otherwise are "wrong 'uns"!
Please check the Law Society's 'Find a Solicitor' database to establish whom it is you are dealing with.
This Solicitors practice is at :- http://solicitors.lawsociety.org.uk/office/545878/equitable-law-limited
My personal details are at:- http://solicitors.lawsociety.org.uk/person/9511/daniel-robert-johnson
Anyone else who is NOT included in that database (both as an individual AND in relation to the legal entity through which they trade) - will be omitted for a variety of reasons - most likely including an inability to satisfy the Solicitors' profession's regulator (directly or indirectly) as to ethics and / or competency (although there is much, much worse that I could advise you of - I am afraid!)
Please always remember that the general ultimate aim of seeking legal advice & assistance in relation to commercial / business matters, is to result in the possession of appropriate advice etc. and / or the production of documents - which you can legally rely upon and / or enforce in the future.
It is fully possible in circumstances (such as these) to opt for 'false economy' and pay for apparent 'legal' advice & assistance - that only much time later do you realise is worthless for your purposes and / or damaging for your position (and in relation to which - in practice - you have no 'comeback')!
If you are comfortable not receiving legal advice & assistance that you can rely upon (and I fully understand that in early stage businesses etc. this can be the case) - there are a range of on-line legal guides and libraries that I would be happy to guide you to - which ultimately are much more economic / cost-effective than paying inflated sums to someone who will simply be regurgitating information that they have fund on-line to you - with no understanding as to its accuracy / appropriateness etc.(at best)!
I sincerely hope that our first contact will not be when you wish to have a consultation with me about the prejudice and resulting losses that you have suffered from not instructing a Solicitor / having instructed the cheapest on-line advice and assistance option - as regrettably happens all too often!
I am always delighted to have preliminary contact with prospective clients upon an initial no obligation basis, so do please feel free to contact me for such a discussion.
I hope to receive contact from you - if you would like to discuss my potential legal advice & assistance further.
DanielRobertJohnson (Skype)
Dan.Johnson@EquitableLaw.com
+44 (0) 7788 537 187 (U.K. Cell. Tel.)
+44 (0) 20 8780 3319 (London Landline Tel.)
www.EquitableLaw.com
Friday, 23 September 2016
Achieving An Effective “Corporate Divorce”
It’s that
time of year (!)
Family lawyers
habitually experience their busiest times of the year (regarding new divorce and
separation instructions) immediately after Christmas and/or at the conclusion
of Summer holidays (apparently - when the stress of being with spouse(s) / life-partner(s) has proved
‘too much’ for many).
Business
lawyers likewise notice an upturn in the habitual friction within quasi-partnerships manifesting itself in a desire for a 'corporate divorce' at around the
same times of the year (and this year has been no different for the writer!), the apparent
motivation being that quasi-partners at around these times find themselves having to
return to business with their quasi- partners (whom they no longer wish to be in
business with).
Quasi-Partnerships (?)
The phrase 'quasi-partnership' is used in this discussion to describe a small number of individuals who (as owner / managers) co-operate in a venture / business in a manner similar to a partnership (but that is carried on through the legal structure of a limited liability company).
For various reasons,
quasi-partnerships often reach a natural ‘fork in the road’ (say - simply, as the business has developed), and the
quasi-partners then wish to separate their affairs.
While a generally stressful and difficult time for those involved, matters are not helped by the fact that (while there are considerable practical and taxation reasons for using a limited liability company as a legal structure for a venture / business), limited liability companies were not designed for, nor are necessarily natural structures for operating quasi-partnerships conveniently, and there are a range of aspects & issues with their structure which complicate matters (particularly with regard the exit of a quasi-partner).
While a generally stressful and difficult time for those involved, matters are not helped by the fact that (while there are considerable practical and taxation reasons for using a limited liability company as a legal structure for a venture / business), limited liability companies were not designed for, nor are necessarily natural structures for operating quasi-partnerships conveniently, and there are a range of aspects & issues with their structure which complicate matters (particularly with regard the exit of a quasi-partner).
First-Steps
Every circumstance
is different, so the writer suggests that the first stage in resolving matters is to ask an
appropriately qualified and experienced business adviser (such as the writer) to
fully analyse the current legal position of the relevant quasi-partnership and report
upon what can be achieved in the particular circumstances, and the suggested
approach to take.
It should be
recognised in early course that any minority shareholder, in a quasi-partnership
is in a particularly difficult situation in terms of resolving matters with a
majority shareholder (e.g. ask any institutional shareholder in Sports Direct!).
Shareholding structures with a 50-50 deadlocked shareholding are also particularly problematic to resolve.
However, where a clear majority in shareholding is resolved to achieve a ‘corporate divorce’ with a minority shareholder, much can be often be achieved (even if potentially stressful & complex).
Shareholding structures with a 50-50 deadlocked shareholding are also particularly problematic to resolve.
However, where a clear majority in shareholding is resolved to achieve a ‘corporate divorce’ with a minority shareholder, much can be often be achieved (even if potentially stressful & complex).
Ideally the
business adviser should be able to advise across all relevant aspects relating
to the exiting quasi-partner’s interests in the company. Those interests tend to be in relation to the
exiting quasi-partner’s service arrangements, the offices (e.g. directorship) which
the quasi -partnership holds and their shareholding in the company. While closely
related (in practice), the particular legal specialisms to deal with these
different ‘hats’ that the exiting quasi-partner ‘wears’ - can be difficult to
find in a single adviser.
Approach
The preferred
approach in relation to seeking to achieve a corporate-divorce is (if at all
possible) to resolve matters by mutual agreement.
From a purely personal perspective, if a corporate-divorce can be resolved relatively amicably (so that the interested-parties can potentially continue a businesslike relationship in the future) that has to (arguably) be in all parties interests.
However in reality, it is likely that an approach of ‘carrot and stick’ will be needed to focus minds and bring matters to an appropriate conclusion, applied in such relative proportions as circumstances demand.
From a purely personal perspective, if a corporate-divorce can be resolved relatively amicably (so that the interested-parties can potentially continue a businesslike relationship in the future) that has to (arguably) be in all parties interests.
However in reality, it is likely that an approach of ‘carrot and stick’ will be needed to focus minds and bring matters to an appropriate conclusion, applied in such relative proportions as circumstances demand.
If the
analysis has revealed that a corporate divorce would appear to be unilaterally achievable,
then the writer has found that the following is generally the order in which
matters need to be resolved.
Service Arrangements
A careful
understanding needs to be obtained as to the basis upon which an exiting quasi-partner
has been involved with (i.e. provided their services and / or been remunerated
by) the company.
It is
becoming more and more common (particularly in relatively early stage ventures)
to find that the relevant exiting quasi-partner is not an employee of the
business. In such circumstances, a
relatively straightforward review of the contractual relationship by which they
provide services to the venture (e.g. consultancy agreement etc) is required,
and a contractual termination of the relevant arrangements (e.g. by serving
notice etc) is generally all that is required.
Even if the
relevant exiting quasi-partner is held to be an employee of the company, they
may not have served as an employee for a sufficient length of time to have
obtained statutory employment protections (so much the same position applies). At present – and very broadly - an employee
has to have been employed for two years to be able to claim statutory employment
protections.
Great care
must be taken in analysing the factual circumstances, both as to whether an
employment relationship exists and whether statutory employment protections have arisen and are therefore an issue for the relevant company. If they are, then matters will potentially become
considerably more complex (and costly) to resolve.
Hopefully, a sensible discussion on a without prejudice and subject to contract basis with the exiting quasi-partner may lead to a mutually agreed termination of the relevant service arrangements, but this may need to be (at least initially) accompanied by steps to force the issue (e.g. suspension, exclusion from premises and service of notice).
Offices (Directorships)
Those with
majority control of a company subject to a corporate divorce will need to
resolve any offices with the company (e.g. Directorship etc.) which the relevant
exiting quasi-partner holds.
From a
practical perspective, any ability for the exiting quasi-partner to represent
himself as a continuing active director with apparent authority to bind the
company etc needs to be dealt with (at least initially) by whatever practical steps can be taken
(e.g. removing the relevant exiting quasi-partner from bank mandates etc).
However, those with control of a majority of the shares, quite often find themselves in a position where they do not have a expressly
agreed contractual provision (in Articles of Association or elsewhere) which allows the relatively
informal and timely removal of an existing director.
While the
relevant companies legislation provides a procedure for a majority of
shareholders to remove a director, for various reasons this is quite a
time-consuming and administratively cumbersome process to undertake.
Broadly, if a
director can be encouraged to resign voluntarily in relatively short order this
is likely to be a preferred approach, although it may be practically necessary
to start the relevant companies legislation process to achieve this (as ‘a
stick to accompany a carrot’).
Alternatively, if the relevant
majority have an ability to pass a special resolution (requiring a 75%
majority of shares), then it can be quicker and easier to amend the company's Articles of Association to include a provision allowing for a less formal removal of
directors - either by a majority of shareholders and / or a majority of the
existing board.
Shareholdings
Often the
quasi-partner’s shareholding is the most difficult aspect of matters to be
resolved, and it may (in practice) not be possible to do so.
This is
because the Companies' Act Model Articles (often adopted as, or forming the basis of the constitution
of many limited companies) don't contain rights to purchase shares from an
unwilling to sell shareholder, even if the relevant shareholder was also previously actively involved in the company but has now left. The
relevant shares are broadly protected as a property right.
Some
articles, particularly (where well advised external investment has been taken) contain ‘leaver provisions’, allowing a company (or other interested shareholders) to call for a
transfer of the relevant exiting quasi-partner’s shares upon them ceasing to be
actively involved with the company – although these are unlikely to exist in most 'plain vanilla' quasi-partnership
arrangements.
The ongoing
owner / managers may well wish to resolve the position of the exiting quasi-partner's
shareholding, because it is difficult for them to justify the "carrying of
a sleeping partner" into the future. Further, the existence of ‘legacy shareholdings’ can
complicate the ability to run a company (on an on-going basis) and (in
particular) to raise external investment by way of share capital.
Resolving a
legacy shareholding position by negotiation can be hugely difficult because
there is often a huge disparity between the valuations placed upon the shares as
between the exiting quasi-partner (as potentially selling shareholder) and the
continuing shareholders / company (as potential buyers).
Even in
circumstances where an exiting shareholder might be persuaded to sell their
shares at a mutually acceptable valuation figure, there is often a considerable
difficulty in financing such a transaction.
Matters are
considerably simplified if external finance can be obtained for the purpose,
but external equity investors who are prepared to finance a ‘cash-out’ deal are
extremely rare. Often the continuing quasi-partners do not have the necessary
external financial resources themselves to buy the relevant exiting quasi-partner’s
shares.
It is theoretically
possible to undertake a ‘company own-share purchase
transaction’, but in practice the often necessary external bank debt which is required is difficult to obtain. The
practicalities of undertaking such an exercise are hugely complicated by
various aspects of companies legislation which are designed to protect
creditors of the company by ensuring a maintenance of share capital in a
company. Broadly, a company own share purchase transaction generally needs to
be financed from a company’s profit and loss reserves (which are often insufficient
for the purposes) and which (even if possible) is administratively cumbersome and
time-consuming to achieve.
Thankfully,
there are a number of recognised (if ‘secret sauce’!) alternative means of
resolving the exiting quasi-partners shareholding ownership interests by
agreement - without offending companies legislation’s principles of maintenance
of share capital.
Carefully used, they allow a company to finance the practical exit of a shareholder from a share register (and give the effect of the relevant shares having been ‘cancelled’) in a much more flexible manner than a company own-share purchase.
Carefully used, they allow a company to finance the practical exit of a shareholder from a share register (and give the effect of the relevant shares having been ‘cancelled’) in a much more flexible manner than a company own-share purchase.
Negotiations re:
share sale & purchase are considerably assisted if the continuing
quasi-partners have an ability to pass a special resolution of shareholders (≥75%),
since this will potentially allow the adoption of new articles with provisions
introduced (say) as to allow the re-purchase of a leaver’s shares. Great care
has to be taken with such an approach, but such an approach should focus the
exiting quasi-partners mind as to the potential ‘stick to which they may become subject’.
Ultimately, the aim has to be for short, simple and straightforward 'exit' paperwork to be available for signature to encourage a negotiated, and agreed corporate divorce. However, often, more unilateral paperwork to 'force the issue' may also have to be prepared (even if not ultimately utilised).
Thought & care should be taken as to how any relevant exit payments are structured (from a tax perspective - both now and in the future).
Ultimately, the aim has to be for short, simple and straightforward 'exit' paperwork to be available for signature to encourage a negotiated, and agreed corporate divorce. However, often, more unilateral paperwork to 'force the issue' may also have to be prepared (even if not ultimately utilised).
Thought & care should be taken as to how any relevant exit payments are structured (from a tax perspective - both now and in the future).
Should you
wish to discuss the relevant methodologies for achieving an acceptable “corporate
divorce”, please do not hesitate to discuss the same with the writer.
Dan.Johnson@EquitableLaw.com
+44 (0) 7788 537 187 (U.K. Cell. Tel.)
www.EquitableLaw.com
Dan.Johnson@EquitableLaw.com
+44 (0) 7788 537 187 (U.K. Cell. Tel.)
www.EquitableLaw.com
Wednesday, 17 August 2016
A Busy Summer - As Two More Deals Are Closed
Equitable Law (Mr. Dan Johnson) is delighted to report that we have experienced another busy late summer period, somewhat at variance with the writer’s initial view that there might well have been a lull in investment and transactional activity - post the late June BREXIT referendum vote.
Transaction One – Sale of ‘Suresense Technologies’
Equitable law was delighted to assist the selling shareholders with regard to their transfer of the shares in Suresense Technologies Limited based in Newquay, Cornwall.
Suresense Technologies (www.suresense.co.uk) creates energy efficient technology solutions for the energy intensive industrial sector - which are designed to reduce the energy costs for businesses by optimising energy usage (so as to drive company profits and reduce CO2 emissions) and ensure health and safety compliance all over the world.
The purchaser was a new entity established by entrepreneurs well known in the industry sector and backed by Percipient Capital. Percipient Capital (www.percipientcapital.com) (founded by various former of Directors of HSBC Ventures) is a leading independent provider of private equity and venture capital to small and medium sized businesses, and their finance is intended to allow Suresense Technologies to develop further.
Transaction Two – Sale of the Business & Assets of ‘Better Eyewear’
Equitable Law has also recently assisted with the transfer of the business and assets of Better Eyewear Ltd to Spec-Care Ltd (based in Exeter).
Better Eyewear was the UK distributor of “Erin’s World’ spectacle frames, a high-profile design of glasses frames - founded by U.S. entrepreneur, Maria Dellapina (www.specs4us.com) & designed for patients (and especially children) with Down’s Syndrome.
The sale should allow the highly successful UK launch of the product to be further developed under new ownership (with more resources to devote to marketing & distributing the products).
Further details of both transactions are confidential between the parties, although Equitable Law was delighted to be able to assist both sets of ‘sell-side’ parties using our well-developed approach of minimal necessary input to the transactions, seeking to add value (as and where appropriate) but leaving the majority of administrative (/ non-legal) work to be undertaken by the principals involved – this considerably limiting the necessary legal spend incurred by clients.
If you would like to discuss Equitable Law’s assistance with your transactions and our approaches to economic & efficient closing of deals , please do not hesitate to contact the writer
Transaction One – Sale of ‘Suresense Technologies’
Equitable law was delighted to assist the selling shareholders with regard to their transfer of the shares in Suresense Technologies Limited based in Newquay, Cornwall.
Suresense Technologies (www.suresense.co.uk) creates energy efficient technology solutions for the energy intensive industrial sector - which are designed to reduce the energy costs for businesses by optimising energy usage (so as to drive company profits and reduce CO2 emissions) and ensure health and safety compliance all over the world.
The purchaser was a new entity established by entrepreneurs well known in the industry sector and backed by Percipient Capital. Percipient Capital (www.percipientcapital.com) (founded by various former of Directors of HSBC Ventures) is a leading independent provider of private equity and venture capital to small and medium sized businesses, and their finance is intended to allow Suresense Technologies to develop further.
Transaction Two – Sale of the Business & Assets of ‘Better Eyewear’
Equitable Law has also recently assisted with the transfer of the business and assets of Better Eyewear Ltd to Spec-Care Ltd (based in Exeter).
Better Eyewear was the UK distributor of “Erin’s World’ spectacle frames, a high-profile design of glasses frames - founded by U.S. entrepreneur, Maria Dellapina (www.specs4us.com) & designed for patients (and especially children) with Down’s Syndrome.
The sale should allow the highly successful UK launch of the product to be further developed under new ownership (with more resources to devote to marketing & distributing the products).
Further details of both transactions are confidential between the parties, although Equitable Law was delighted to be able to assist both sets of ‘sell-side’ parties using our well-developed approach of minimal necessary input to the transactions, seeking to add value (as and where appropriate) but leaving the majority of administrative (/ non-legal) work to be undertaken by the principals involved – this considerably limiting the necessary legal spend incurred by clients.
If you would like to discuss Equitable Law’s assistance with your transactions and our approaches to economic & efficient closing of deals , please do not hesitate to contact the writer
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
