K.I.S.S. (Off) –
When Keeping It Simple May Well Be Stupid

In
a recent online poll seeking to establish the public’s view of the
greatest invention ever created in the United Kingdom, one high ranking
contender might well surprise you. Admittedly helped by a social media
campaign amongst corporate lawyers (= ‘Sad’ – I know!), a contender
which scored highly was ‘the limited liability company’, a business
structure which was radical at the time of its first creation and in
their initial uses.
Limited liability companies (in their early incarnations) had an
unsurpassed ability to raise large amounts of capital from numerous
investors for significant large scale business ventures (e.g. railways),
allowing the providers of the capital to hope for profits, but be
comfortable that the most they could lose was their investment (as
reflected in their shares) - and (save for that loss) that they had no
responsibility for a venture’s liabilities. Generally, (in their early
incarnations) the shareholders were unlikely to be involved in the
management of the company, and to protect the passive nature of their
‘stake’, company law rules sought to rigidly protect their rights as
shareholders.
However, modern business life has seen limited liability companies
habitually used in numerous much smaller ventures, frequently with very
limited (if any) initial capital requirements (often no more than a
nominal sum), and with the various ‘stakeholders’ generally being
closely involved in the management of the venture (i.e. as directors of
the company).
These business structures are (in truth) ‘quasi-partnerships’, and
arguably would be more appropriately structured as partnerships, i.e.
akin to those utilised by accountants and solicitors etc. Partnerships
generally allow a much more flexible approach to stakeholder interests
in the business, crucially being much easier structures within which to
make adjustments between partners as businesses evolve and the partners’
roles within them change (as inevitably happens - over time).
However, until relatively recently, the only readily available and
easily accessible U.K. business structure which provided the crucial
advantage of limited liability was a company, generally formed with
liability limited by shares. Even though the U.K. business landscape
now has legal business vehicles such as the limited liability
partnership, for various reasons – including, predominantly the
relatively low corporation tax rates on retained profits which limited
companies enjoy, this has meant that - the vast majority of
quasi-partnership structured businesses continue to operate within a
structure of a limited liability company.
It is now possible in this internet age for entrepreneurs to form
limited liability companies online in a matter of minutes (and at a very
low cost). Often the limited time expended in such a process (and the
negligible costs involved) means that thoughts over the structure
receive little (if any) attention. Further, the lack of experienced
professional input (often absent - due to limited funds for
professionals fees in the early stages of a business) means that the
structure which is settled upon is remarkably simplistic and with very
constrained ability to change – leaving it fraught with potential future
problems.
This situation is referred to as the ‘Dragons Den syndrome’ (after
the TV show of that name), where the moneyed backers of any particular
venture are limited (by the producers) to only two criteria, the amount
of cash to be invested and the proportion of pure equity stake which the
backers might receive in the particular business in return for that
cash.
The reality is that most venture capitalists, (including most of the
half-dozen or so individuals who have appeared on Dragons Den over the
years) use much more sophisticated ownership structures in relation to
their investments, because those backers appreciate that they need to
put in place structures which can evolve over time and (crucially) which
allow the managers that the ‘Dragons’ are proposing backing to be
incentivised on a long term basis so as to produce a ‘win-win situation
for all’.
However, to revert back to the reality of business life – we are
often approached by businesses which are owned within stakeholder
structures which have arisen (or evolved) with limited (if any)
appropriate professional input, often still reflecting a simplistic
position which was settled in the early or historic stages of a
business, and which structures are now not conducive to the further
development of the particular business – in many cases limiting the
potential to create much larger value (for all stakeholders).
If these situations are not resolved, the feelings of frustration
experienced by important stakeholders with the lack of fairness in the
business structure can often seriously impair the ability of the
business to progress and expand, and at worst, may lead to a
catastrophic shareholder dispute (to the extreme detriment of the
underlying business and its stakeholders).
The types of problems that we see are numerous (and confidentiality
does not allow us to outline examples), but they can (for example)
include historic founders of businesses, who now feel that they are
entitled to be ‘sleeping partners’ (i.e. cease to have active
involvement in the business, and that the other stakeholders should
carry them as passengers), and / or new or second tier management who
feel that their shareholding stake in the business does not adequately
reflect the increase in value of the business which they consider they
are creating.
We are regularly approached in the early stages of potential business
sale transactions where the stakeholders know that if they could
resolve their current stakeholder issues, they may well together be able
to successfully expand their business at a much faster rate, creating
significantly more value (for the benefit of all) in a subsequent
transaction.
If you would like an analogy, ‘the bakers’ have prepared a cake mix
with clearly defined portions - but they know that if they could adjust
those ‘stakes’ so that everybody felt in agreement with fully
co-operating further in ‘the baking process’, the cake might
successfully rise - so that their ‘bit of the cake’ might be
considerably larger than may otherwise be the case - for the benefit of
all involved (Work with me on this one!).
Often the stakeholders know that they have an issue which would
potentially benefit from being resolved between them, but the party who
is in the first instance initially at an advantage (under the historic
structure), is often reluctant to make the first move, thereby
potentially showing a ‘sign of weakness’.
Alternatively, the party who is in the first instance initially at a
disadvantage (under the historic structure), may well be extremely
motivated to ‘resolve the position’, but does not have the experience
nor expertise to propose an alternative structure which produces an
equitable (i.e. fair and reasonable) result between the stakeholders.
The underlying business’ established professional advisers may be
hopelessly compromised in terms of assisting the stakeholders. In a
worst-case scenario - it may have been them who actually produced the
structure which is now experiencing problems; or (frequently) because
they are closely aligned with certain stakeholder(s) who are most
reluctant to change the status quo, usually being the holder(s) of the
majority stake in the relevant business.
Matters become further complicated because any ‘transaction in
securities’, in layman's terms any arrangement by which current value is
transferred from one of the stakeholders to another of the stakeholders
may well give rise to charges to taxation (which if nothing else can be
agreed upon, is clearly understood by the stakeholders as being
something to be avoided!).
We have repeatedly found ourselves able to assist business owners in
terms of revising their ownership stakes, profit shares and management
arrangements for the good of all.
Getting the relevant interested parties ‘around the table’ is only
possible when each stakeholder can foresee the benefits of the proposed
revised structure, and consider that their ‘slice of their pie’ is to be
a fair one. In next month’s article: “An Offer You Cannot Refuse – or –
A Horse’s Head in Your Bed” we will ‘drill down’ into motivators for
effecting an reorganisation of stakeholder interests, including ‘carrot
and stick’ approaches.
http://www.evolutioncapital.com/news-articles/an-offer-you-cannot-refuse
An Offer You Cannot Refuse

Last month I reviewed the merits of a limited liability company (and
the potential considerable drawbacks in the way that stakeholder
interests are habitually structured within them).
I was subsequently (reminded by a colleague) of a Paul Weller song as sung by David Bowie:
”Oh we’re absolute beginners, with nothing much at stake”.
The nothing (in a company starting up) may well become something of
substantial value in a few years, with the potential to soar even
further. Alternatively, if potential issues with stakeholder interests
(arising after start up) are not addressed, that value may ‘level off’,
decline or in a worst case scenario plummet.
In this month’s
article we discuss the pitfalls where the equitable re-distribution of
ownership (and the accompanying benefits) can be problematic at best and
un-achievable at worst.
Often, most of the solutions revolve around the principle of being
able to calculate the current market value of the business (which has
been achieved under the current stakeholder ownership structure). Once
this has been established, it can form the underlying basis of
formulating how (in particular) the ownership of any additional market
value (which might be subsequently created in the business) might be
agreed shared between the various ongoing stakeholders.
As external advisors, focused upon ensuring that the relevant
business develops to become of a higher value – we can often help as
‘honest brokers’ (Copyright: Otto von Bismarck), in being able to put
forward proposals & negotiate and / or mediate to put in place a
revised stakeholder ownership structure for the next stages of the
business’ development.
It would be naive of me to intimate that such negotiations and / or
mediations revolve solely around the potential benefit (or ‘carrot’)
elements of revising the structure, since all stakeholders need to be
aware of the potential detriment (or ‘stick’) in not resolving their
differences, and there may be a need for further ‘sticks’ to be
‘intimated’ to those who are reluctant to amend the structure.
Many film buffs will be familiar with the phrase ‘made them an offer
they cannot refuse’ from Francis Ford Coppola’s original ‘The Godfather’
film (based upon the novel by Mario Puzo). When the phrase is first
elucidated by ‘Michael’ (Al Pacino) to ‘Kay’ (Diane Keaton) in the
opening wedding scene, it is used to graphically illustrate the forced
re-negotiation of ‘Johnny Fontane’s (the - not unlike - Frank Sinatra
character’s) management contract - with the band leader who held the
benefit of the same:-
"So the next day, my father went to see him; only this time with Luca
Brasi. An' within an hour, he signed a release, for a certified check
for $1000. [Kay: "How'd he do that?"] My father made him an offer he
couldn't refuse. [Kay: "What was that?"] Luca Brasi held a gun to his
head and my father assured him that either his brains, or his signature,
would be on the contract.
However, when you closely analyse the subsequent use of the phrase
within the plot of ‘The Godfather’ [The Corleone family’s efforts to
‘win’ ‘Johnny Fontane’ a part in a forthcoming movie], you will come to
(arguably) appreciate that if (say) the fictional Hollywood movie mogul
had accepted Don Corleone’s lawyer’s / consigliore’s (‘Tom Hagan’ /
Robert Duvall’s) offer on behalf of his client, for the minor
‘complication’ of conceding that ‘Johnny Fontane’ should appear in the
mogul’s forthcoming picture, Don Corleone would make that film mogul's
union problems ‘go away’ – to the likely overall benefit of the movie
mogul.
It was (arguably) an excess of macho posturing and unwillingness to
concede sensibly proposed arrangements which led to the horse’s head
ending up in the movie mogul’s bed.
Thus ‘the offer [all stakeholder parties] cannot refuse’ needs to
reflect a negotiated solution whereby all of the stakeholders
(hopefully) do not lose (at least – not materially) and that they have
an opportunity to ‘win-win’ in the future – which otherwise potentially
or actually would not occur.
Put another way, if Francis Ford Coppola and Robert Duvall had
managed to mutually satisfactorily resolve their actor’s fee
negotiations for the final (and last) instalment of the film series
(which they apparently failed to do), then the script for ‘The Godfather
Part III’ would not have had to be completely rewritten - so as to
remove the character ‘Tom Hagan’ (to the obvious detriment of the film
and seemingly its financial success), and Robert Duvall might have put
in a performance which would have won an Oscar (while finding his bank
balance more than adequately filled - both for that and subsequent film
performances).
We aim is to ensure that the legal processes
involved in a potential transaction are an integral part of a successful
project - with the aim of ensuring a smooth progression to the eventual
transaction - so as to efficiently and economically take the interested
party principals from initial discussions through to completion. Often
that involves all stakeholders in non-adversarial negotiations and / or
mediations prior to the transaction occurring, in which each party is
led to a realisation that agreeing to a proposed universally
satisfactory solution is in all parties’ long term best interests.
Equitable principals of fairness and reasonableness are crucial to this
process.
Finally, in the bastardised words of Tom Hagan (and so that you are in no doubt as to my love of ‘The Godfather’): –
“We have a special practice. We handle you as if we have one client. Now you have our number, we'll wait for your call.”